Home improvement Magazines

How corruption, regulatory failure gasoline Nigeria’s tragic constructing…

Constructing collapse, with lack of lives, is turning into frequent in Nigeria. On this report by OLADIMEJI RAMON, trade specialists establish corruption and regulatory failure because the elements behind it; in addition they talk about the way in which out

On the morning of Tuesday, November 3, 2021 the environment on Gerrard Highway, Ikoyi, Lagos, was charged and pensive. Anybody approaching was first confronted with a car of the Federal Highway Security Corps parked obliquely in the midst of one lane of the twin carriageway.

Forward, scores of safety brokers and emergency employees buzzed round. A ways aside, a line of anxious-looking individuals had been both seated or pacing the sidewalk. Greater than a dozen tv cameras had been set down and several other journalists milled round. Most gazes had been fastened on two excavators working their methods by a mountain of rubble. It was nearly unimaginable to overlook the strain within the air amid agitated and hushed discussions happening in numerous mini teams.

This was an uncommon scene in Ikoyi, a complicated Lagos neighbourhood, reputed for its serenity. But it surely was the third day of tense emergency operations after a 21-storey constructing underneath building caved in on November 1. The fallen edifice was one, and the tallest, of a set of three breathtaking high-rises, named 360 Levels Towers, being constructed by Fourscore Heights Restricted.

Tragedy struck proper in the midst of the busy hours of the day, thus, lots of the employees on web site had been trapped.

On the primary day of the tragedy, 9 individuals had been rescued alive however by the second day, the rescue operation had turned to a seek for useless our bodies.

By the third day when this reporter visited, households, who had been certain their lacking family members labored on the web site got here round, praying and hoping for a miracle.

Once in a while, hope gave technique to despair and pent-up nervousness. By per week later when the search operation got here to an finish, demise toll had hit 46, together with the proprietor of the constructing, Femi Osibona, his private assistant, Oyinye Enekwe, and his United States-bound pal, Wale Bob-Oseni.

The autumn of the 21-storey high-rise and the attendant excessive mortality determine marked one of the tragic moments for Nigeria in 2021. However as monumental as this tragedy was, it is among the many frequent circumstances of constructing collapse within the nation lately, particularly in Lagos – Nigeria’s financial capital.

This worrisome scenario persists regardless of all of the regulatory measures put in place to tame it. This, trade specialists and numerous fact-finding tribunals have linked to poor enforcement of rules and sharp practices within the trade.

In response to them, corruption within the Nigerian constructing building trade manifests in type of use of substandard constructing supplies, desire for quacks, weak enforcement by the regulatory our bodies and alleged bribery of state officers who compromise within the enforcement of trade guidelines, significantly the place influential builders are concerned.

Using substandard constructing materials, they defined, is pushed by builders/ contractors’ desperation to chop prices on the expense of security. This, in response to specialists, accounts for majority of the circumstances of constructing collapse within the nation.

Collapse of a dream

A former President of the Constructing Collapse Prevention Guild, Mr Kunle Awobodu, described the Ikoyi incident as “the mightiest constructing collapse in Nigeria’s historical past.”

Certainly, the autumn of that high-rise was extra than simply the collapse of a constructing; it was the collapse of a dreamed revolution within the Nigerian actual property sector. In an August 6, 2021 interview with TVC, which went viral after the tragic incident, the proprietor of the constructing, Osibona, had laid naked his dream.

It was apparent that with 360 Levels Towers, which he additionally fondly known as “Luxurious within the Sky”, Osibona deliberate to make a press release that the perfect has but to be seen of the potential that exists within the Nigerian actual property trade and he noticed himself main the way in which into that promising future.

The property developer was fairly infectious within the method wherein he spoke about what he had envisioned. As he continually defined, his mission was to construct residential flats equal in luxurious to a typical seven-star resort. As he defined, this dream was impressed by a go to to a pal in London “dwelling in a really large home (price about £5m) with white individuals.”

The challenge was mentioned to be 80 per cent prepared and 65 per cent of the flats, provided for between $500,000 (N206.6m) and $3m (N1.24bn), had been already subscribed when the skyscraper crumbled. And Osibona’s dream was even past 360 Levels Towers.

“No matter you might be seeing right here is only the start. It’s simply two to a few per cent of our subsequent challenge. I can let you know, the long run may be very brilliant. So, that is only a youngster’s play… For me, we’ve got simply began. All these high-rises we see in Dubai, we may have them in Nigeria. It’s a matter of time,” he had mentioned.

Fallen 21-storey high-rise spotlights trade rot

Hours after the collapse of that constructing, the Lagos State Governor, Mr Babajide Sanwo-Olu, ordered a probe into the incident and subsequently inaugurated a six-man panel, which was given 30 days, to hold out the duty.

The governor, who admitted that “certainly errors had been made,” additionally suspended the Basic Supervisor of the Lagos State Constructing Management Company, Gbolahan Oki, indefinitely.

Whereas the state panel’s report remains to be being awaited, observations by specialists counsel that a few of the recognized elements behind constructing collapse in Nigeria had been at play within the execution of the ill-fated Ikoyi high-rise.

Quickly after the 21-storey high-rise crashed, the location attracted the curiosity of specialists within the constructing building trade.

Throughout their visits, professionals nosed round for preliminary indicators of what might have gone incorrect. A lot of them mentioned a easy have a look at the signboard to the challenge was sufficient to arouse suspicion that one thing was not proper.

For instance, the President, Architects Registration Council of Nigeria, Dipo Ajayi, who visited the location together with his colleagues on November 3, mentioned it was curious that the signboard didn’t disclose the names of the professionals engaged, opposite to the usual follow.

The signboard, standing tall on the entrance, didn’t disclose the names of the contractor, idea designer/challenge supervisor, structural engineer and the architect. Solely telephone numbers had been displayed and that of the structural engineer was even lacking.

Ajayi mentioned, “From what we’ve got seen right here, from the signboard, we didn’t see the identify of the architect or the engineer. I’m not making an attempt to preempt the panel, however as an architect and President of ARCON, there ought to be a properly organised system the place individuals may have their place within the trade.”

Expressing an identical view in an interview with Channels TV, the present President of the BCPG, Mr George Akinola, mentioned, “The regulation says it’s essential to put a board there that exhibits the professionals concerned within the constructing or the development happening. Nothing exhibits the architect; nothing exhibits the structural engineer; nothing exhibits the amount surveyor and all the opposite professionals that ought to be concerned. There may be nothing about them.

“They only wrote some acronyms after which telephone numbers. However that’s not the skilled technique to do it. (From) the signboard there, it’s very clear that there’s a contravention, type of.”

It was later discovered that the structural engineer in command of the challenge, one Prowess Engineering Restricted, had withdrawn, stating, through a February 20, 2020 letter, that “We now not share the identical imaginative and prescient with you as our shopper by way of how the challenge is being executed.”

Prowess Engineering Restricted, within the letter signed by its Managing Director, Muritala Olawale, mentioned it couldn’t assure the integrity of the high-rise.

“We request that our firm’s identify and brand be faraway from the challenge board and in addition kindly notify all mandatory approving authorities of our withdrawal from the challenge,” the structural engineer mentioned.

However the first glimpse of a attainable breach of rules and malpractices was given by the suspended LABSCA GM, Oki, when shortly after the constructing fell, he blurted out in an interview with the Information Company of Nigeria that the developer, Osibona, raised the constructing in extra of what was authorized.

“He (Osibona) received an approval for a 15-storey constructing and he exceeded his restrict. I’m on floor right here (web site of collapsed constructing) and the supplies he used are so inferior and horrible.

“The supplies he used, the reinforcement, are so horrible. He received approval for 15 flooring however constructed 21,” Oki mentioned.

Many analysts mentioned it was curious that regardless of that Oki had such info, LABSCA, underneath his watch saved mute whereas the developer carried on until tragedy struck.

However the existence of attainable energy play and compromise evident in conditions when the developer is influential and well-connected, emerged when shortly after the Deputy Governor of Lagos State, Dr Obafemi Hamzat, contradicted Oki, insisting that 21 flooring had been authorized.

Hamzat mentioned the constructing was at a degree sealed off, however was later reopened for corrective work.

In an interview with Sunday PUNCH, ex-President of Constructing Collapse Prevention Guild, Awobodu, remarked that, “when those that are immediately concerned are saying one factor and people on the increased degree are saying a distinct factor, it means lots is incorrect.”

In the meantime, the Nigerian Establishment of Structural Engineers, which launched an unbiased probe into the incident, later confirmed in its preliminary report launched on November 15, 2021, that certainly Osibona overshot the authorized restrict for the high-rise.

Within the report signed by its President, Dr Kehinde Osifala, the NIStructE mentioned its findings confirmed that, “The constructing that collapsed was initially designed for simply six flooring, and later (raised) to 12 flooring, earlier than this was additional modified to fifteen flooring.

“It couldn’t but be established the adequacy of any properly-designed and documented additional revision to the eventual (and tragically, closing) 21 flooring that was being applied and which collapsed.”

The report added, “Lack of correct high quality management and high quality assurance measures and processes in the course of the building was evident turning into noticeable as seen within the poor high quality of concrete supplies and workmanship noticed in the course of the examination of the collapse particles.”

The autumn of the Ikoyi high-rise has put the highlight on the regular rot in Nigeria’s constructing building trade. It revealed that the rot has remained regardless of the suggestions made by probe panels set as much as examine earlier main constructing collapse incidents within the nation.

As a pointer to the endemic nature of the menace, barely 24 hours after the incident, a bit of a two-storey constructing, additionally underneath building within the Osapa London space of Lekki, Lagos, additionally caved in. Thankfully, nobody died.

However 4 individuals misplaced their lives when one other two-storey constructing, underneath building at Flour Mill Property, Magbon in Badagry, Lagos, collapsed two weeks later.

That the nation is witnessing rising collapse of buildings underneath building helps the submission by specialists that corruption, manifesting in using sub-standard supplies, quackery and failed trade rules, is on the root of the issue.

Prevalence of constructing collapse

The Ikoyi incident comes seven years after the September 12, 2014 collapse of a six-storey visitor home belonging to the Synagogue Church of All Nations within the Ikotun space of Lagos. The incident claimed 116 lives.

Following a probe, the Lagos State Authorities mentioned it established that there was no approval for the constructing.

The Council of the Regulation of Engineering in Nigeria, which carried out an unbiased probe, mentioned the constructing lacked satisfactory basis, including that there was no proof it was supervised by a structural engineer.

To assume that the development allegedly escaped the discover of regulatory companies earlier than tragedy struck was a pointer to weak enforcement or compromise.

The nation has additionally witnessed the collapse of a six-storey constructing being constructed by Lekki Gardens within the Lekki space of the state in March 2016. No fewer than 34 individuals died within the incident.

As within the case of SCOAN constructing, the state authorities additionally found after the tragedy that the constructing was not authorized.

In Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, over 100 individuals died when Reigners Worldwide Church’s constructing caved in on worshippers in 2016.

There was additionally the collapse of a seven-storey constructing underneath building in GRA Section 2, alongside Woji Highway, Port Harcourt on November 24, 2018, which claimed 18 lives and injured 22 others.

A probe panel arrange by the River State Authorities equally established a case of compromise, including that the constructing was raised in extra of the authorized restrict.

Nigeria has additionally witnessed the collapse of a three-storey constructing within the Ita Faaji space of Lagos Island on March 13, 2019, which killed 20 individuals, together with some pupils of Ohen Nursery and Main Faculty, occupying the second flooring of the distressed constructing.

With these circumstances and extra, the nation has, certainly, paid dearly for corruption and regulatory failure within the constructing building trade.

Although it’s tough to know the precise variety of constructing collapse circumstances within the nation as a result of lack of sufficient knowledge, the BCPG, an advocacy group of constructed setting professionals, reported that in 2019 alone the nation witnessed 43 circumstances of constructing collapse.

In 2017, a report by the Federal Ministry of Energy, Works and Housing indicated that 54 buildings collapsed throughout the nation in 4 years.

A tally by The PUNCH additionally confirmed that at the least 145 buildings collapsed in Lagos State between 2007 and 2021. The tally additional confirmed that between 2014 and 2021, no fewer than 259 individuals died from constructing collapse incidents in Nigeria’s industrial nerve centre and most populous state.

Sadly, the menace stays untamed.

Why buildings collapse

A report by Discovery Channel, United States offers an summary of attainable causes a constructing might collapse or fail.

The report notes that constructing collapse is a world phenomenon to which even technologically-advanced nations should not immune.

Solely on June 24 this yr, the USA of America witnessed the collapse of a 12-storey condominium within the Miami suburb of Surfside, Florida. Described as one of many deadliest constructing collapses within the US historical past, the autumn of the 40-year-old apartment claimed 98 lives with 11 others injured.

In South Korea, Sampoond Division Retailer collapsed in 1995, killing greater than 500 individuals and injuring over 937 others.

In 2013, Bangladesh misplaced at the least 1,132 souls to the collapse of an eight-storey manufacturing unit in Dhaka.

World over, constructing collapse incidents have change into eye-openers and have gotten specialists within the building trade considering.

The Discovery US’ report narrowed the explanation why buildings fail or collapse right down to 4. They’re design flaws, floor settling, overloading and materials deterioration.

Floor settling

In response to the report, when a construction is constructed on unstable land, comparable to mushy soil of marshland, the inspiration can start to sink shortly after building and this will get worse with time.

It acknowledged, “When the inspiration fails, the constructing collapses from the underside. In a high-rise constructing, this ends in a pancake impact, the place the higher flooring slam down on prime of the collapsed basis.”


The report famous that buildings are designed to assist a sure most load.

“A constructing can collapse if there may be extra weight on a portion of it than the construction is designed to assist. This could occur when the fabric’s power deteriorates over time,” it mentioned.

Design flaws

In response to the report, a constructing, whose design fails to make room for various load paths or redundancies, is doomed to fail.

The report mentioned, “Buildings are sometimes designed with redundancies or various load paths. If one part of the construction fails or weakens to the purpose the place it may now not maintain the constructing’s weight, then that load is redistributed to a different part. Designs that lack such redundancies can result in devastating failures of the complete construction.”

Materials deterioration

“Chemical modifications in supplies, comparable to rust burst, may cause buildings to break down,” the report famous.

It defined that metal, embedded in concrete to strengthen buildings, can time beyond regulation increase as much as six or seven instances its authentic thickness.

“This growth (of the metal) can crack the encompassing construction and when cracks seem, rain and frost trigger the cracks to widen, rendering the constructing unsafe,” the report acknowledged.

Corruption worsens Nigerian situation

However moreover these 4 elements recognized within the report, specialists say the conditions of the Nigerian actual property sector are peculiar, compounded by corruption.

This was alluded to in a analysis paper titled, ‘Constructing Collapse in Nigeria Throughout Latest Years – Causes, Results and Method Ahead,’ authored by P. O. Awoyera, J. Alfa, A. Odetoyan and I. I. Akinwumi of the Division of Civil Engineering, Covenant College, Ota, Ogun State.

The report acknowledged that, “Lots of the documented circumstances of constructing collapse in Nigeria are as a consequence of using faulty or substandard constructing supplies, no requisite technical data, non-adherence to constructing codes and requirements, using non-professionals and the excessive degree of corruption, which has ravaged each sphere of the development trade together with authorities and personal parastatals.”

Additionally, the Basic Supervisor, Lagos State Supplies Testing Laboratory, Mr Olufunsho Elulade, in an October 10, 2021 interview with Sunday PUNCH, acknowledged that, “Essentially the most prevalent trigger (of constructing collapse in Nigeria) is using dangerous supplies. Sadly, we discovered ourselves in a spot the place individuals wish to minimize corners. Once you give a challenge to a supervisor, the supervisor desires to maximise his revenue in order that they connive with others to purchase faux supplies.”

A retired director within the Abia State Ministry of City Planning and a former Chairman, Nigerian Institute of City Planners, Abia State Chapter, Elder Nelson Nwaosu, additionally informed our correspondent that quackery is a significant drawback within the Nigerian building trade.

Nwaosu mentioned, “You realize that in Nigeria, a mason now places himself ahead as an engineer. You will notice somebody who’s educated to mould blocks claiming to be an engineer. Quackery is overwhelming.”

Osibona’s revealing interview

In his August 6, 2021 interview with TVC, the developer of the collapsed 21-storey high-rise, Osibona, revealed one thing necessary about himself – that he had a observe file of in some way getting approval to construct greater than what he initially meant and utilized for.

The late property developer claimed that it was by no means a fault of his however the errors of the approving authorities, which he noticed nothing incorrect in exploiting.

By his personal admission, he did it first in London – on two completely different events.

He mentioned, “There was an enormous home; I utilized for a two-storey extension. The council needed to jot down two-storey, they made a mistake; they wrote three-storey. After we began growing it, neighbours went to report – you understand the place you could have two-storey buildings in London, you’ll be able to’t do a three-storey (constructing), two-storey (buildings) should go all the way in which.

“So, they went to report me to the council and the council got here and agreed that they made a mistake however they mentioned I mustn’t do the three-storey, anyway. I went on and did the three-storey. Then we went for a committee; on the committee, I gained.”

Then he did it once more.

He mentioned, “There was this home I purchased in London, it nonetheless exists at the moment, they name it Fourscore Mansions in Hackney, 113 Abion Drive. It was a pub; the pub was to be demolished after which I utilized for a planning permission to develop a five-storey constructing…By the point the planning approval got here in once more, the council made some errors; they needed to jot down six-storey, they made a mistake, they wrote seven-storey.”

The ill-fated Ikoyi high-rise adopted nearly the identical sample, solely with the distinction that the choice to exceed the authorized restrict was not tied to a mistake by the approving authorities.

This was revealed by the now suspended LABSCA GM, Oki, in addition to the preliminary report by the NIStructE.

Why constructing approval is necessary

Ex-Chairman, Nigerian Institute of City Planners, Abia State Chapter, Nwaosu, mentioned opposite to the considering of many builders, approvals for buildings should not granted arbitrarily, such that one might determine to overshoot it.

He defined that for a constructing above one flooring, soil integrity and the kind of supplies for use for the constructing are the elements thought-about in granting approval.

Nwaosu mentioned, “Typically, after the bottom flooring, in a storey constructing, which we name two flooring, we think about the power of the soil and the kind of supplies for use. And that’s the reason typically, if it’s a storey constructing, which is 2 flooring, we wish the structural engineer to stamp on it, confirming to have seen the kind of supplies for use.

 “We additionally require the geology or the geo-technical skilled to affirm the kind of soil and the power of it, which is named soil check.”

However in spite the significance of grant of approval or allow within the constructing course of, current circumstances of constructing collapse confirmed that builders generally ignored it, whereas there isn’t a or scant file of the culprits being punished.

The place the state manages to provoke prison proceedings in opposition to errant builders and contractors, such trials are sometimes pissed off by long-winded judiciary processes, which take a few years.

For example, following the collapse of SCOAN’s six-storey guesthouse in 2014, the Lagos State Authorities charged the registered trustees of the church with one rely of “constructing with out approval” in violation of Part 75 of the City and Regional Planning Legislation of Lagos State 2010.

The contractors in command of the challenge, Oladele Ogundeji and Akinbela Fatiregun, alongside their firms, Hardrock Development and Engineering Firm and Jandy Belief Restricted, had been equally charged with involuntary manslaughter.

However seven years after, the courtroom has but to provide a verdict and nobody has been punished.

Within the case of Lekki Gardens’ collapsed three-storey constructing, the agency’s Managing Director, Richard Nyong, and 7 others had been charged with six counts of constructing with out approval and involuntary manslaughter.

After three years of forth and again actions in courtroom, the prosecution later got here up with a questionable plea cut price, which the choose, Justice Sybil Nwaka, angrily rejected.

For the collapsed seven-storey constructing in GRA Section 2, alongside Woji Highway, Port Harcourt in 2018, a probe panel arrange by the Rivers State Authorities discovered that the developer,  Francis Allagoa, didn’t initially acquire a constructing allow, and although he later obtained approval for a five-storey constructing, he determined to boost the construction to seven flooring.

Performing on the advice of the panel, the state introduced its choice to prosecute the developer, his engineer, Adeniyi Ibiyeye, in addition to architect, Timiebi Reuben.

However three years after, nothing has been heard of such prosecution, underscoring impunity and absence of deterrence whereas the menace of constructing collapse stays unchecked.

A former Lagos State Solictor-Basic, Lawal Pedro (SAN), mentioned it wasn’t for lack of satisfactory legal guidelines however lack of enforcement that constructing collapse stays untamed within the nation.

He mentioned, “The difficulty of constructing collapse is a severe one. As I’ve all the time mentioned, lack of enforcement is a significant subject regarding constructing collapse.”

A Lagos-based lawyer, Mrs Aderemi Fagbemi, nevertheless, known as for the simplification and fast-tracking of the method by which constructing allow is granted.

Fagbemi, who’s the Secretary to the Development Tasks and Infrastructure Committee of the Nigerian Bar Affiliation Part on Enterprise Legislation, mentioned the bureaucratic bottleneck is among the causes many builders bypass due course of and undergo the again door by bribing officers.

Fagbemi famous {that a} current evaluation by the World Financial institution revealed that in Lagos State, as an example, “buyers and builders need to undergo 17 procedures to acquire (constructing) allow which is estimated to take about 118 days.”

The lawyer mentioned, “The allowing, inspection and certification processes must be lowered and simplified to encourage builders, and there’s a must discontinue bodily/paper purposes, with a view to scale back the avenues for corrupt practices.

“For the developer, they should make sure that the method is seamless and that state actors won’t search to frustrate their investments by unnecessarily stalling the grant of approvals with a view to acquire a bribe or purely due to inefficiency.”

Fagbemi’s recommendation reiterated the advice made in 2014 by a Lagos Justice of the Peace and coroner, Mr Komolafe Oyetade, who carried out an inquest into the demise of the SCOAN constructing collapse victims.

The Justice of the Peace had really useful that “authorities ought to scale back the price of acquiring mandatory constructing permits or approval and take away administrative bottlenecks with a view to encourage people and organisations to undergo the due technique of acquiring mandatory constructing permits or approval earlier than the graduation of constructing constructions.”

Copyright PUNCH.

All rights reserved. This materials, and different digital content material on this web site, might not be reproduced, revealed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in entire or partially with out prior categorical written permission from PUNCH.

Contact: [email protected]

Related Articles

Back to top button